National recruiting experts have weighed in on BYU’s 2025 football signing class, and while the overall consensus is positive, it’s clear that the Cougars’ recruiting efforts are solid but not spectacular. As BYU transitions to the Big 12 Conference, there is a growing expectation that the program will need to elevate its recruiting game to compete with the powerhouses in the new conference. The 2025 signing class, while a step in the right direction, has left some analysts questioning if it will be enough to establish BYU as a true contender in the Big 12.
Strengths of the Class:
The Cougars’ 2025 recruiting class has several positives. For one, BYU continues to tap into its traditional recruiting areas, particularly in Utah, where the Cougars have long been a dominant force. A significant portion of the class is made up of local talent, many of whom are considered to be among the best in the state. BYU has done well to secure commitments from a number of top-tier athletes in Utah, particularly on the offensive and defensive lines, which is crucial for success in the Big 12, where physicality is often a determining factor in games.
Additionally, BYU has maintained its reputation for developing high-character athletes. With the university’s commitment to its Honor Code, the program has attracted players who align with its values. This approach has earned the Cougars respect on the recruiting trail, as parents and coaches value the program’s commitment to developing young men both on and off the field.
Room for Improvement:
While BYU has made strides, it’s clear that the 2025 signing class isn’t quite at the level of some of the top Big 12 programs, especially when it comes to recruiting nationally. National recruiting experts have pointed out that while the Cougars have landed a handful of quality players from other states, they’ve missed out on several high-profile recruits who have committed to other Power Five programs.
One key area of concern is the defensive backfield. BYU has secured a few solid recruits at cornerback and safety, but experts argue the class lacks the elite talent that programs like Oklahoma, Texas, and Kansas State are bringing in. The secondary is one area where BYU will need to improve to handle the high-powered passing offenses that dominate the Big 12.
Another aspect that stands out is the lack of top-tier skill position players, particularly at quarterback and wide receiver. While BYU has some solid prospects at these positions, the recruiting class doesn’t feature a standout quarterback prospect that could potentially step in and make an immediate impact. This is a notable gap for a team that will need explosive playmakers to compete with the Big 12’s offensive juggernauts.
The Bigger Picture:
BYU’s transition into the Big 12 will require a significant leap in recruiting, especially as the Cougars aim to compete with established programs that have been recruiting at a high level for years. The 2025 signing class, while certainly a solid foundation, will need to be complemented by strong future recruiting classes to truly elevate BYU’s standing in the conference.
The Cougars are also facing increased competition in their own backyard. Utah’s rise as a perennial Pac-12 contender has made it more difficult for BYU to lock up the best talent in the state. While BYU’s strong religious affiliation and commitment to developing well-rounded individuals will continue to be selling points, the program will need to continue adapting to the demands of high-level recruiting.
In conclusion, BYU’s 2025 football signing class is solid but not spectacular. As the Cougars move into the Big 12, it will be crucial for the program to continue improving its recruiting efforts to stay competitive. While this class provides a solid base, more work will be needed to bring in elite talent capable of propelling BYU to new heights in its new conference home.
Leave a Reply